Suggestions
Explore the featured selections!
Scully's Classic
Pistachio Ricotta Cake
Tuna Salad On Greens
Roasted Beet Salad
About
Scully’s Restaurant
Welcome to Scully’s Restaurant, a hidden gem nestled in the heart of Silver Lake, Wisconsin. Located at 107 S Cogswell Dr, Scully’s is more than just a dining establishment; it is an experience that transports you through culinary delight. Known for its extraordinary service and vibrant atmosphere, Scully’s offers a menu filled with flavorful dishes that celebrate both classic favorites and innovative choices.
Why Scully's Stands Out
- Exceptional Seafood: Dive into the oceanic flavors with dishes like the Mahi Mahi Piccata Gratin and the Classic Salt & Pepper Salmon. Each dish perfectly balances taste and texture, making every bite a celebration of fresh ingredients.
- Irresistible Fish Fry: As raved by patrons like Kat Kretschmer, the fish fry here is a must-try. Opt for the "lightly battered" option and savor the exquisite perch special or walleye, served with flawlessly prepared potato pancakes—an unexpected standout.
- Salads that Shine: Don’t overlook the salad offerings. From the Scully’s Chop to the delectable C.O.B.B, each salad is a colorful mélange of textures and flavors, perfect for a refreshing start or a light main course.
- Drinks with a Personal Touch: The Scully’s Old Fashioned has received accolades for its reminiscent quality, transporting patrons back to fond memories of handcrafted cocktails. Brian Adamson’s nostalgic review captures this sentiment perfectly.
- Comfort in Every Bite: Reviewers rave about the hearty comfort food, like the potato pancakes that surpass even the fondest childhood benchmarks. Desserts, particularly the chocolate mousse, leave guests yearning for more.
At Scully’s, the emphasis is on fresh, real ingredients that translate into dishes bursting with flavor. Each review reflects a deep appreciation for not just the food, but the warmth and charm of the dining experience. Patrons like Becky Kroncke and Dan have highlighted the vibrant flavors and outstanding service that make a visit to Scully’s a necessity.
Whether you seek a cozy dinner with friends or a lively night out, Scully’s Restaurant promises a memorable experience that you won't want to miss. With an inviting atmosphere and a menu that caters to all tastes, it is the perfect place to gather, share, and indulge in culinary excellence. Come visit and see why Scully’s is set to become your new favorite dining destination!
People talk
Our Guestbook
“ Folks .. you need this fish fry in your life. Get the "lightly battered" option, we had the perch special, and the walleye. I don't even generally like potato pancakes, and these.... look at them. They are perfect. The staff is a delight. I will be back. Soon. ”
“ Don't drive too fast or you'll pass this jem by. It might look small but the flavors were huge! We can't wait to come back and experience more of what they have to offer. ”
“ Ok, I rate food and drinks by past experience. I’ll start with the drink order. I ordered the Scully’s Old Fashioned. My benchmark is from my grandfather. He made them with such detail and care. They were the best and I have never been able to find one that came close until the one from Scully’s. It is my grandfather’s Old Fashioned reincarnated. I ordered the Walleye dinner. Again, my grandfather, who was a great fisherman, had fish fry dinners after his trips to Canada. He fried the walleye in lard with a beer batter. It was the best tasting fish I’ve ever had. I rate all fish fries after that. Again, I have not had anything better until the walleye at Scully’s. It is my grandfather’s reincarnated. Next, I had the potato pancakes as a side. My benchmark for potato pancakes was my mom’s. They were not good at all (sorry mom). Don’t get me wrong, she was a great cook. In fact we used to say that she should be a caterer. Anyway, that ruined me for potato pancakes. I kept trying them over the years and never found any I liked until Scully’s. So tasty. I will get them every time I go to Scully’s, which will be every chance I get. Don’t get me started on the desert. The chocolate mousse was great. You know sometimes the chocolate mousse at some restaurants is basically just chocolate pudding. This was not. It has a chocolate cake bottom crust and a chocolate fudge top crust. Fantastic. Oh yeah, we had the fried pickles for a starter. Better than Hooters, which is where they started and were considered the benchmark. Scully’s is my new benchmark for all the items I had. ”
“ Fabulous food! extraordinary service with a smile! And quite possibly the best corned beef on the planet!! Thank you!! ”
“ The food is amazing!!! It’s real, fresh, and there aren’t enough words to describe the incredible flavor. I can’t wait to come back to try everything!! ”
“ Scullys is one of our favorite breakfast spots so when we heard they were opening for dinner we had to try it. Dinner was amazing! The homemade rigatoni with vodka sauce was delicious and the handmade 4 cheese, sausage and spinach pizza was so good. Portions are huge so come hungry ! ”
“ Got there at opening. Wasn't crowded at all. Was a very warm and inviting place. The waitress, Anita was very nice and super attentive. I ordered the special, the chicken fried steak. First time I had a hand battered one. It did not disappoint. The whole meal was absolutely delicious. I highly suggest eating there and ask for Anita to be your waitress. ”
“ We stopped in at Skully's on Friday for their fish fry. We were very impressed. I am originally from the Green Bay area and moved here 20 years ago. I could never find a good place for a Perch Plate in the Kenosha area until today. Skully's hit it out of the park for me. Perch was simply delicious and the potato pancakes were awesome. Other restraunts in this area have frozen perch, then fried and potato pancakes that tastes like flour, not at Skully's. I reccomend people to get fish at this place. Keep in mind, I ordered a double perch plate in this photo. ”